Dear GLBTQ Book Awards People, (and you know, I know, you know, who you are), would our awards have a greater impact on the book-buying public (yes, they exist) and culture in general if we gave out fewer awards in fewer categories without gender-specific/sexual-orientation-limiting standards? Awards mean more when there’re fewer of them to give.
This isn’t kindergarten, and everybody doesn’t get to win a prize. That’s what makes prizes so great — they’re exclusive to one winner. Take a note from a few other awards orgs.
The National Book Critics Circle Awards recognizes the best book in six categories: autobiography, biography, criticism, fiction, nonfiction, and poetry.
The Man Booker Prize given annually by the The Booker Prize Foundation in the UK awards one lone book with a prize of UK$50,000.
The Pulitzer Prize for Fiction, though it awards writing in many, many categories, only gives out one fiction award.
American Library Association’s John Newbery Medal is given to the author of the most distinguished contribution to American literature for children. One award each year.
The Stonewall Book Award from the ALA honors two GLBTQ authors annually in two categories Literature and Non-Fiction Award. Done, and done.
Related posts:
- Don’t expect to see David Leavitt and Edmund White at the queer publishing awards UPDATED: It’s red carpet season for the queer book industry. Both the Lambda Literary Foundation and the Publishing Triangle will give out awards to the...
- Fancy Book Awards | The Nobel Prize RED CARPET SEASON for the book world is in full swing. Think horn-rimmed eyewear and sensible shoes in place of Balenciaga gowns and vintage...
- Queer Literati @ Lambda Literary Awards (EXCLUSIVE) Some of the biggest names in GLBT literature held court at the 21st annual Lamba Literary Awards hosted by Scott Nevins on Thursday night....
- In Brief: Publishing Triangle Awards The Publishing Triangle Awards were held at the The New School’s Tishman Auditorium in Chelsea last night. Legendary gay historian, Martin Duberman was honored...
- GLAAD Advertising Awards Winners A QUICKIE | The premier GLAAD Media Awards in Advertising took place Tuesday, October 27th at New World Stages in New York City. Actor Alan...
-
First, I love your blog. I’m not gay, I’m not a man, but I am a reader and lover of words and your blog fits the bill! I’m not sure this comment is going to the right story because it’s about the Lambda Awards.
I agree with the giving out of fewer, more prestigous rewards without gender requirements (not exactly how you said it). I lost interest in the Lamdas several years ago. I’d heard rumors that they have a sort of unofficial rule that they won’t shortlist or give a prize to a book about men written by a woman or a book about women written by a man. I didn’t believe it, and looked up past lists of nominees and winners. It certainly appeared that the rumor was true.
I don’t know much about lesbian books because I’ve read very few, but I can say this about books written about men by women: the good, such as Patricia Nell Warren, Ruth Sims, Mary Renault as examples, are very, very good. The bad, like JL Langley and most of the ebooks out there, write porno trash with very little story and lots of you-know-what spelled out. It took Warren, author of The Front Runner for godsake! years before they condescended to give her even a lifetime achievement awards, or whatever they called it. Maybe the problem is that the obviously female authors should have lied and used initials or goofy pen names that are gender neutral. But they didn’t, apparently, want to lie. Well, they can give out Lammies twice a year for all I care. Unless they become more open a pox on them. Personally it doesn’t affect me. I’m neither author nor publisher, but I do believe fair is fair.


1 comment
Comments feed for this article
Trackback link: http://www.homo-neurotic.com/2009/03/25/queer-books-awards-less-is-more/trackback/